“Lilly Potter:
Survivor Of Titanic”

By Savanna R. Fisher

(click all photos to enlarge)


Lily A. Potter
(1855-1954)

Col. Thomas Potter Jr.

Lily Alexnia Potter

Location:

Known As:

Laurel Hill Cemetery East
Section : J
Plot: 106

~ Survivor of Titanic


Lily Alexnia Potter. What a wonderful woman. I was first introduced to her by my father on one of our first trips to Laurel Hill Cemetery . He had just got their app and was trying to figure out how to use it. He wanted to make me feel more comfortable and less freaked out about being in a cemetery. I have always had a fear of cemeteries, dead bodies and the unknown that surrounds it, so, this was very out of my element. Without telling me, he decided the first person we were going to look for was going to be a Titanic passenger. Now, how he decided that it was going to be Lily Potter, I have no clue. To the average human, the most appealing Titanic passenger at Laurel Hill would be the Wideners or William Dulles. I guess what I'm trying to say is someone in a mausoleum. But I am so glad that when he was picking a passenger he chose Mrs. Potter.

It took us about 45 minutes to find the Potters. Maybe because it was our first time using the app or maybe because I was attached to his hip, too scared to be left behind. When we finally found her, it quickly became the cutest and most cozy place in the cemetery, or at least it is for me. She has a cute little bush right in front of her plot and a tree for some shade along with a tiny wall to separate her plot from her neighbors. My dad and I are standing by the plot and realized oh wow I never asked who or what exactly we were looking for. “Okay so who is this” I say to my dad. He looks at me with his “your gonna be so proud of me” look on his face. He tells me “two Titanic survivors”. He points to the memorial obelisk and says “it should be Olive and Lily”. And for the first time I feel and sense of comfort in the in the cemetery. I have watched Titanic so many times that I could talk about it for hours. The movie really has become a great comfort for me. I felt my eyebrows relax and my jaw come unclenched. My body was relaxed. At the time I didn't know a thing about her. The second we got home I looked her up and when I saw her picture, I got the chills. I found an article about her and read it. She absolutely amazed me. I don't remember when the idea of writing her bio was presented to me, but I jumped at the opportunity. Now, every time we go down to Laurel Hill, I make it a point to go see Lily. I have spent countless hours researching her to find anything I could. Partially because I can share it with others and partially because I'm extremely interested. She feels like a family member and gives me a sense of comfort. I will tell her story to anyone that will listen.

Lily was born August 15th 1855. Her parents, Seth W. Wilson (1827-1911) and Martha A. Thompson (1829-1922), raised her in Michigan. Lily later moved to Philadelphia in 1870, where she met and married her husband, Thomas Potter Jr. (1850-1910) in 1876. He became a part of the national guard in Pennsylvania. He received a medal for assisting the survivors of the Johnstown flood of 1889. Lily also sent a trained nurse to aid in the aftermath. The couple went on to have 3 children, Wilson Potter (1880-1946), Thomas Potter III (1887-1894), and Olive Potter (1888-1958).

In 1894, Thomas Potter III died of heart failure brought on by pneumonia at the age of 17. Col. Thomas Potter Jr. also passed away in 1910 at the age of 60.

Wilson Potter

Olive Potter

In December of 1911, Lily decided to take Olive, who was getting divorced, on a vacation to Europe. The two also decided to invite one of Lily’s friends, Margaret Hays (1887-1956), who went to Radcliff Elementary School with her in New York. Margaret brought her Pomeranian dog named “Lady”. The trio toured Italy and the Middle East. When they were finished with their travels, they booked a different passage to return home. As they were about to leave Turkey, they heard about the RMS Titanic and how amazing it would be for them to travel on her. They decided that even though Titanic would not set sail for another week, it would be worth the wait and canceled their original ship.

Lady

Margaret Hays

The Titanic arrived at Cherbourg, France on April 10,1912. Lily was in cabin C-50, Olive and Margaret were in C-54. Gilbert Tucker (1880-1968), the three ladies' self-appointed “escort”, stayed in cabin C-53.

Gilbert Tucker

It was late Sunday night, and all three girls were in bed. Lily was not yet asleep. She felt the ship scrape against the side of something. Shortly after, the engines stopped. Margaret and Olive went into Lily’s room and Lily told them to go see what the issue was. About ten minutes later, the two returned. They informed Lily that they had hit an iceberg but a steward told them they should not worry and they should go back to bed. Lily suggested that they should not stay in their room. The three tried to prepare for swimming by doing things such as not wearing corsets because it could prevent them from swimming. While recounting the story, Lily says “oddly I thought of such a thing and never realized the water had been terribly cold.” Margaret wrapped her Pomeranian in blankets. Gilbert Tucker helped the three ladies put on life jackets before putting on his own. Lifeboat 7 was the fist one ready for boarding. Ladies were asked to come forward. Lily heard someone near her say “the captain wants to lighten the ship while repairs are being made”. The three ladies stepped on the lifeboat (still with the dog), followed by Gilbert Tucker, who was allowed on the lifeboat to continue to “protect” the ladies. The boat was lowered at 12:45 A.M.

Someone on the lifeboat felt water on their feet, they quickly realized the drainage plug was not in and put it back in as soon as they could. There was no food or water aboard the lifeboat. The Titanic was sending out distress signals and Lily was watching six of the portholes on the ship. As the number of portholes showing was lessening, she knew two things: the ship would perish along with the souls on board and that they made a good choice of taking the lifeboat. The lights of the Titanic suddenly went out. The ship disappeared from sight.

Lily recalls that the screams were too horrible for words. Everyone on the lifeboat drifted and did not make any effort to return to the wreckage. The RMS Carpathia came to the rescue by sunrise. By the time it was Lily’s turn to climb the rope ladder, her hands were too cold to grab on so she decided to use the rope swing. During the return trip to New York, the three ladies as well as Gilbert did all they could to help those who left their family and friends behind. Margaret even went as far as to become the guardian of the two Navratil Brothers after their dad passed in the wreckage. At Pier 54, the Potters met up with their family and so did Margaret.

RMS Carpathia

In 1920 Olive was remarried to Allen Crolius (1889-1936). The two went on to have two sons, Allen and Thomas. Unlike Lily, Olive continued traveling and took Allen and their two sons to Spain and she sailed to Bermuda on many occasions. Her husband passed away in 1936 from congestive heart failure at the age of 47.

Allen Crolius, Olive Potter Crolius with their sons, Allen & Thomas

Lily, after seeing such tragedy, now wanted to help people like herself and others that were aboard the Titanic. During World War I, she began volunteering for the southeastern Pennsylvania chapter of the American Red Cross. She worked, managing thousands of volunteers to collect and manufacture products needed for hospitals overseas. In 1944, Lily was awarded the Gimbel Award for 27 years of service to the Red Cross. Olive continued being a volunteer the rest of her life assisting in both World Wars. It was January 1, 1954 when Lily passed away of congestive heart failure at the age of 98. She was interred at the beautiful Laurel Hill Cemetery. Olive went on to volunteer for the red cross for the rest of her life. Olive died of Cancer on April 21, 1958. She was also buried at Laurel Hill with her mother. Section J, Plot 106.

The Potter Family Plot
Laurel Hill Cemetery
Section J
Plot 106

Col. Thomas Potter Jr.
(1850-1910)

Lily A. Potter
(1855-1954)

Olive Potter Crolius
(1888-1958)

Savanna R. Fisher
&
Lily A. Potter

Savanna R. Fisher
Portrait


Be sure to hear more about Lily Potter as well as other passengers on April 14th on the special tour:
Unsinkable to Unthinkable: Titanic Passengers of Laurel Hill.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
All content by
Savanna R. Fisher
©2024 Liberty Belle
All Rights Reserved.